About Defonte’s Sandwich Shop

Defonte’s Sandwich Shop, a legendary establishment located at 379 Columbia Street in the Red Hook neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York City, has been delighting locals and visitors with its iconic deli sandwiches for well over a century. This historic gem is not just a place to grab a sandwich; it’s a cornerstone of the Italian-American culinary experience and a testament to the enduring legacy of traditional, mouthwatering deli fare. Since its inception in 1922, Defonte’s has been a cherished culinary destination, originally catering to the Italian longshoremen who frequented the Brooklyn waterfront.

Fast forward to today, and you’ll find an eclectic mix of patrons queuing up for the vast and delectable sandwiches. It’s a place where culinary history, heritage, and timeless flavors collide. Defonte’s Italian american Sandwiches isn’t just a place to eat; it’s a culinary institution, a living testament to the enduring love of Italian-American flavors, and a slice of history in the heart of Brooklyn’s Red Hook neighborhood. It’s where the past and present converge to create unforgettable culinary memories, one colossal hero sandwich at a time.

Exploring the Defonte’s Menu

When you step into Defonte’s Sandwich Shop, located in the historic neighborhood of Red Hook, Brooklyn, you’re in for a treat. As a local establishment with a rich culinary history, Defonte’s has a menu that’s packed with a variety of mouthwatering options that will satisfy every sandwich craving. One of the standout features of Defonte’s is the Staten Island influence on the menu. The Red Hook menu is a testament to the commitment to providing the finest deli-style sandwiches, which have kept customers coming back for over a century.

For those seeking a classic breakfast sandwich, the potato and egg is a must-try. This delightful sandwich, served warm on Italian bread with mozzarella, is the perfect way to kickstart your day with a blend of savory and comforting flavors. Defonte’s also offers a catering menu, ensuring that you can bring the deliciousness of the sandwiches to your special events and gatherings. Whether it’s a corporate luncheon or a family celebration, the catering options have you covered with a delectable spread that’s sure to please your guests.

The Best Seller at Defonte’s

Hot Roast Beef

You’ll find a trio of mouthwatering sandwich options that have left an indelible mark on the menu. First up, let’s dive into the delectable world of the Hot Roast Beef sandwich. This savory creation is a true delight for meat lovers. Tender slices of perfectly roasted beef are generously piled onto fresh Italian bread, creating a hearty and satisfying sandwich. The rich, juicy beef is complemented by a luscious gravy that adds a touch of indulgence to each bite. It’s a classic comfort food experience that’s both filling and comforting, making it a beloved choice among patrons at Defonte’s.

Chicken Cutlet

Moving on to the Chicken Cutlet sandwich, you’ll be treated to a crispy and flavorful delight. At Defonte’s, the chicken cutlet is prepared to golden perfection, with a crispy, breaded exterior that encases tender, succulent chicken meat. This sandwich is a wonderful blend of textures, as the crunchy cutlet meets the soft Italian bread. Additionally, you can customize your sandwich with a range of toppings and condiments to suit your preferences, from fresh veggies to zesty sauces. It’s a fantastic option for those craving a satisfying and substantial poultry-based sandwich.

Steak Pizzaiola

The Steak Pizzaiola sandwich is a unique and tantalizing offering at Defonte’s. This sandwich is a fusion of Italian flavors and American sandwich craftsmanship. It features tender slices of steak, prepared to perfection and seasoned with a medley of savory spices. What sets it apart is the pizzaiola sauce, a zesty and tomato-rich concoction that infuses the steak with a burst of mouthwatering flavor. The combination of the steak’s tenderness and the boldness of the sauce makes this sandwich a standout choice. When you bite into this masterpiece, you’ll experience a harmonious blend of textures and tastes that is sure to leave a lasting impression.

Experience the Comfortable Atmosphere at Defonte’s

When you step into Defonte’s, you’ll immediately sense that you’re not just walking into any ordinary sandwich shop. The moment you enter Defonte’s, the hustle and bustle of the Red Hook neighborhood seems to fade away. The scent of freshly baked bread and the sound of friendly chatter fill the air. It’s a place where locals, tourists, and sandwich enthusiasts of all ages come together to enjoy a shared passion for mouthwatering deli creations.

The interior exudes a sense of nostalgia, with old-timers engaging in animated conversations while waiting for the orders. The walls of this historic establishment are adorned with memories and stories, a testament to its long and storied history. This is where generations of sandwich lovers have gathered, leaving a legacy that’s as rich as the flavors of the sandwiches themselves.

Convenient Delivery Services

For all the devoted fans of Defonte’s Sandwich Shop, the store got some exciting news to share. The iconic eatery, nestled in the heart of Red Hook, Brooklyn, has recently introduced a brand-new addition to enhance your dining experience: convenient delivery services! The convenience of ordering Defonte’s sandwiches online or by phone is a game-changer. No more worrying about sold-out favorites or long lines.

Plus, you can enjoy the same quality and taste you’d expect from a visit to the original shop. It’s like having a little piece of Brooklyn’s culinary history brought to your doorstep. Whether you’re a long-time fan or a newcomer looking to experience a taste of authentic Italian-American tradition, Defonte’s delivery services make it easier than ever to satisfy your cravings. Order online or give them a call, and enjoy the convenience of Defonte’s sandwiches, right when and where you want them. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to savor the flavors of this historic eatery in the comfort of your own space.

take action now

Services Options at Defonte’s

The outdoor seating area at Defonte’s is a fantastic spot to savor your gigantic sandwich while relishing the neighborhood’s unique vibe. It offers a charming setting where you can bask in the pleasant weather, enjoy the company of friends and fellow food enthusiasts, and truly savor the mouthwatering creations of this renowned sandwich shop.

If you’re in a hurry or simply prefer to savor your Defonte’s sandwich in the comfort of your own space, the takeaway option is the ideal solution. With takeaway, you can conveniently order your favorite colossal sandwich and have it expertly prepared to go. Whether you’re on your way to work, heading to the park, or just prefer a cozy meal at home, Defonte’s ensures that you can enjoy the delectable sandwiches wherever you please.

Cash-Only Policy at Defonte’s

Defonte’s Sandwich Shop, one of the key aspects that sets it apart from many modern eateries is its strict cash-only policy. The decision to stick to cash is a throwback to an earlier era, maintaining a tradition that dates back to the establishment’s opening in 1922 when plastic and digital transactions were not part of the culinary landscape. Today, as you join the eclectic mix of customers, including local regulars and curious tourists, you’ll notice that everyone is ready with cash in hand to savor the delectable sandwiches.

This cash-only approach is part of Defonte’s authentic charm. It keeps things simple and straightforward, allowing the focus to remain on the glorious sandwiches. From the famous Nicky Special bursting with Italian flavors to the unique Valentino Special with its crispy fried eggplant, Defonte’s commitment to the cash-only policy is a reminder of its rich history and commitment to preserving the old-school deli experience..

Add Customer Reviews

The restaurant encourages guests to actively participate in the review process by using the form on the website, since this enables them to contribute significantly to the objective assessment of the restaurant’s delicious food and flawless service. Your insightful recommendations are invaluable to anyone considering a visit to Defonte’s.

Great lunch spot

October 18, 2023

took a risk and visited a new location. It was delicious, so I was definitely right to be adventurous. Both the food and the service were excellent; I heartily recommend both.

Avatar for Traveltime146


October 7, 2023

Whoa, those subs are insane! We don’t actually eat subs much because we’re from London, but I wish we did now! Very yummy and a great pick. I would highly suggest taking the stroll from bustling Brooklyn.

Avatar for Katherinew

Since 1922

October 5, 2023

Everything is extremely solid here—fish Friday with shrimp and calamari, golden boy, Enzo, Giuseppe, and egg sandwiches.

Avatar for PStant

South Brooklyn

October 1, 2023

My sister and two additional brothers make up my 66-year-old family. As a longshoreman, my father worked in Red Hook. My father used to cash his paycheck at a checking cash location under the BQE because, in those days, bosses would hand out paper checks when they were paid. His car was a 1966 Chevy Impala. We knew we were heading to Defonte’s when he paid his paycheck, so we all got in the car when he went to do so. We adore the location, the folks, and the cuisine. In fact, I’m leaving work early today, and Defonte’s is my first destination. Oh, and my mother appeared to ensure that my father handed her the majority of his paycheck (LOL).

Avatar for SalvatoreP44

The Real Deal

September 28, 2023

We recently visited Defonte’s in Brooklyn and had to stop there for enough sandwiches to feed a family! We had the Golden Boy (chicken parmesan with prosciutto), the Enzo (roast beef plus+++), and the corned beef (with Swiss, mustard, and cole slaw)—all of which were delicious! Even though I have a big appetite, I could barely eat half of a “small” corned beef! Drenched it all with a glass of chilled Stella! $3 stouts! The proprietor was really friendly and brought over a container of fried shrimp and their homemade sauce for us to sample. The sauce was the greatest! I could have consumed the sauce on its own with a piece of bread! Note: Al fresco dining at the picnic tables in the lot next to the store and

Avatar for Timetraveler09

Read more at Tripadvisor and Yelp!

Following the Map to Defonte’s